第7次是revise,第8次终于是接收

2011-06-10 18:48 · wangtong

早上5点47,老板发了邮件和短信给我们。 在被CNS三巨头的editor拒掉,被NCB杂志review 2次拒掉2次,被Neuron review1次拒掉1次之后,文章的第七次投稿终于在DC被revise,然后在补了1个半月的control和投回38天的等待之后,终于接收了

早上5点47,老板发了邮件和短信给我们。

在被CNS三巨头的editor拒掉,被NCB杂志review 2次拒掉2次,被Neuron review1次拒掉1次之后,文章的第七次投稿终于在DC被revise,然后在补了1个半月的control和投回38天的等待之后,终于接收了,从09年7月第一次投,到11年5月底editor通知我们接收,2年来的悲催,终于看到了结果。看到上一次提出n多问题的reviewer同意我们发表的回复,真是百感交集。

Reviewer #1:

The authors have answered my requests.

Reviewer #2:

The authors added more controls to the membrane prep experiments to show that A regulates membrane association of B; they also included B antibody immunostaining results in the new submission and the data are in agreement with the previous experiments. They provide a reasonable explanation for the different axon morphology caused by overexpression of B or A. Finally they have performed several new experiments to show that C may not be a target of A. I am satisfied with the changes.

Reviewer #3:

The authors addressed all my concerns. This is an important and beautifully executed study. I recommend publication.

我们的努力没有白费,yeah!

我终于赶上了学位评议的末班车,能够在7月拿到学位。虽然我错过了所有的奖项的评定,在CV里,在award的那一栏,始终是空白。但是这篇文章终于发了,而且发得不错,心里总还是出了一股恶气。

压抑阿姨终于舒服了一些。

关键词: